If you run a local business, having a Google Business Profile (GBP) is one of the most important steps to improve your visibility online. Nearly 46% of Google searches focus on local intent, and businesses with optimized profiles are 70% more likely to get visits and 50% more likely to convert those visits into sales. Without a GBP, your business risks being invisible in local search results, missing out on traffic from Google Maps and the Local Pack.
Here’s the breakdown:
- Optimized Profile: Boosts local search rankings, builds trust, and drives customer actions like calls, bookings, and visits.
- Incomplete or Unclaimed Profile: Lowers visibility, allows inaccurate edits, and reduces trust.
- No Profile: Excludes your business from key search areas like Google Maps and the Local Pack, making it harder for customers to find you.
For small businesses, creating and maintaining a GBP is a free and effective way to attract local customers and increase sales.
Google Business Profile Impact: Optimized vs Unclaimed vs No Profile Comparison
1. Optimized Google Business Profile
When your Google Business Profile is fully optimized, you’re giving Google exactly what it needs to connect your business with local customers. Google uses three key factors to rank local profiles: relevance, distance, and prominence. A complete profile ensures you provide the detailed information Google relies on to evaluate these factors, giving your local search visibility an instant boost.
Local Search Visibility
An optimized Google Business Profile can significantly improve your local search presence. Businesses with accurate and complete profiles experience 18 times higher search visibility compared to those with incomplete information. This can be the difference between showing up in the highly sought-after Local Pack or being buried in later search results. And it’s worth noting that the Local Pack accounts for 42% of all local search clicks.
The choice of your primary business category is critical. For instance, selecting “Italian Restaurant” instead of the broader “Restaurant” helps Google match your business to the most relevant searches. Additionally, maintaining consistent NAP (name, address, phone number) information across all platforms is vital. Conflicting details can confuse search engines and hurt your rankings. Beyond visibility, this consistency fosters trust and engagement with potential customers.
Customer Engagement and Trust
A fully optimized profile doesn’t just improve your ranking – it also builds credibility. With 87% of consumers using Google to evaluate local businesses, having a complete profile makes your business 2.7 times more likely to be seen as reputable. High-quality photos and timely responses to reviews further establish trust. Darren Shaw, a recognized expert on Google Business Profiles, emphasizes:
"Most businesses are doing Google Posts all wrong. They treat their Google Business Profile like a social media profile, but it is NOT. GBP is the one platform that people visit with the intent to BUY, so lean into that."
Adding features like a pre-filled Q&A section and business attributes (e.g., “Wheelchair Accessible” or “Women-Led”) shows transparency and engagement, which resonate strongly with customers.
Conversion Actions
An optimized profile doesn’t just attract more views – it drives action. Features like click-to-call, directions, website visits, direct messaging, and appointment bookings make it easy for potential customers to engage with your business. These interactions are critical because Google tracks them to measure your profile’s relevance. High engagement can, in turn, improve your rankings even further.
For service-based businesses, integrating direct booking options through third-party tools simplifies the process, letting customers schedule appointments without leaving Google. These actions not only increase your traffic but also give you a competitive edge in local SEO by turning searchers into customers.
2. Unclaimed or Minimal Google Business Profile
Leaving your Google Business Profile unclaimed or incomplete can lead to serious issues with your business information. When a profile is unclaimed, it becomes static and outside of your control, allowing anyone to suggest changes to critical details like your hours, address, or phone number. If these changes are inaccurate and go unnoticed, customers might show up only to find your business closed or unreachable.
Local Search Visibility
The difference in visibility between a minimal profile and a complete one is massive. Google’s local search algorithm depends on detailed and accurate information to connect businesses with user search intent. Without key details – like business categories, attributes, or service areas – Google has a hard time ranking your profile. This means your business might only appear in searches for your exact name, missing out on broader “near me” or service-related searches that bring in new customers.
As Claire Carlile from BrightLocal explains:
Your Google Business Profile is an excellent example of where business-created content and user-generated content merge… a business can never truly ‘control the message’ [if the profile is unmonitored].
This lack of visibility doesn’t just hurt rankings – it also impacts how customers interact with your business.
Customer Engagement and Trust
An incomplete profile doesn’t just lower your ranking; it also sends the wrong message to potential customers. With 87% of people using Google to evaluate local businesses, and users being 2.7 times more likely to trust a business with a complete profile, an incomplete one can make your business seem unprofessional and unreliable. You also miss out on tools that foster engagement, like responding to reviews, answering questions in the Q&A section, or using Google Messaging. Without these features, it’s harder to build transparency and trust. On top of that, negative reviews or inaccurate customer photos can go unchecked, further damaging your reputation.
Conversion Actions
A bare-bones profile can also hurt your chances of converting searchers into customers. Essential features like "Book" or "Call Online" may not be available or functional. If users filter search results by criteria like “Open Now” or “4 stars and up,” your business might not even make the list if these details are missing. The numbers speak for themselves: businesses with complete profiles are 70% more likely to get visits and 50% more likely to turn those visits into purchases.
3. No Google Business Profile
Not having a Google Business Profile (GBP) puts your business at a severe disadvantage in local search. It’s worse than having an unclaimed or incomplete profile – it’s like being invisible to customers actively searching for businesses like yours. Without verification, your business is excluded from the Local Pack and Google Maps entirely.
Local Search Visibility
Without a GBP, your business misses out on one of the most valuable digital spaces for local search. You won’t appear in the Local Pack – those three map-based results at the top of Google Search – and you’re absent from Google Maps, whether users are searching on desktop or mobile.
This lack of presence means losing nearly half of potential local search traffic. While competitors with GBPs are showing up in "near me" searches and category-specific queries, your business is left to compete for standard organic rankings – if you manage to rank at all. Even worse, organic results often appear well below the Local Pack and paid ads, areas where fewer users scroll. Without access to these prime spots, your business risks losing visibility and credibility.
Customer Engagement and Trust
A missing GBP doesn’t just hurt visibility – it damages trust. Platforms like Google (66%) and Google Maps (45%) are the most trusted sources for researching local businesses, even more than a company’s own website (36%). If potential customers can’t find you there, they may question your legitimacy. They lose access to vital details like your location, operating hours, and reviews, which are crucial for building confidence.
This lack of trust comes with real consequences. Customers are less likely to take a chance on a business they can’t verify, especially when competitors provide all the transparency and social proof they need directly on Google.
Conversion Actions
Without a GBP, you’re also missing out on key conversion tools. Features like "Get Directions", "Call", or "Book Online" buttons are unavailable. Instead, customers have to dig through search results, find your website, and navigate to a contact page – all extra steps that often drive them toward competitors.
Many users don’t even visit websites anymore. They rely on Google’s search results to find everything they need – hours, contact info, menus, and even photos. Darren Shaw, a GBP expert, highlights this shift:
Your Google Business Profile is the one platform that people visit with the intent to BUY.
sbb-itb-5b82b38
Pros and Cons
Every type of Google Business Profile setup comes with its own set of trade-offs that impact how visible your business is, how much trust it builds, and how effectively it drives conversions.
An optimized profile puts you in the driver’s seat. You control your business details, engage directly with customers, and gain access to features like "Book Online" or "Order" buttons that turn casual browsers into paying customers. Plus, it boosts your ranking in the Local Pack and ensures you’re prominently displayed on Google Maps. The catch? It’s a commitment. You’ll need to stay active – posting updates regularly, replying to reviews, and keeping an eye on user-generated content.
On the other hand, an unclaimed or minimal profile leaves you in a risky position. While you might show up in some search results, your business information is exposed to public edits, which could lead to inaccuracies – whether intentional or accidental. Without verification, you miss out on trust-building elements like recent photos or owner responses to reviews. This lack of credibility can hurt your ranking and eliminate access to tools that drive conversions.
Having no profile at all is like being invisible in the world of local search. You’re completely excluded from the Local Pack and Google Maps, which means missing out on nearly half of local search traffic. Considering that 66% of consumers trust Google more than a business’s own website for local research, not being on the platform essentially hands potential customers over to your competitors.
Conclusion
Having a well-optimized Google Business Profile is a game-changer for local search visibility. With 46% of all Google searches focused on local intent and 72% of consumers turning to Google to find local businesses, skipping this step could mean losing out on nearly half of your local audience.
To make the most of your profile, start by claiming and verifying it. Ensure your NAP (Name, Address, Phone) details are accurate and consistent, select the right categories, and actively engage by posting updates and responding to reviews weekly. Adding at least three interior and three exterior photos can increase direction requests by 42%. Don’t forget to populate the Q&A section with common customer questions – this keeps you in control of the information presented.
For businesses short on time, a professional setup can turn an inactive profile into a lead-generating tool. UENI, a Google whitelisting partner since 2017, offers a comprehensive setup service. For under $200, they handle everything – from creating your website to verifying your Google Business Profile – all within seven days. Their Growth Plan even includes ongoing optimization and access to a personal marketing coach, ensuring your profile remains active and competitive.
FAQs
How does optimizing your Google Business Profile boost local search rankings?
Optimizing your Google Business Profile is all about making sure your business details – like your name, address, phone number, operating hours, and services – are accurate and up to date. This not only helps Google get a clearer picture of your business but also boosts your chances of showing up in relevant local searches.
To take it a step further, include high-quality photos, encourage customer reviews, and select the most fitting business categories. These small but impactful actions can improve your profile’s visibility, helping your business rank higher on Google Maps and local search results. The easier it is for nearby customers to find you, the more likely they are to choose your business.
What happens if my Google Business Profile is unclaimed or incomplete?
If your Google Business Profile is incomplete or hasn’t been claimed, your business might have a tough time showing up on Google Maps or in local search results. This makes it harder for potential customers in your area to discover you, which can negatively impact your local SEO and visibility within your community.
A fully completed and verified profile can make a big difference. It boosts your chances of ranking higher in local searches, helps establish trust with customers, and ensures that important details – like your address, business hours, and contact information – are easy to find. Without it, you could miss out on valuable local traffic and opportunities to grow your business.
Why is it important for local businesses to have a Google Business Profile?
Having a Google Business Profile is a must for local businesses. It helps your business show up on Google Search, Maps, and the Local Pack – places where people frequently look for nearby services. Without it, you’re missing out on a free and powerful tool that can build trust, bring in new customers, and boost your local SEO.
With a Google Business Profile, you can highlight key details like your address, hours, contact info, and customer reviews. This makes it easier for potential customers to find and connect with you. It’s a straightforward way to stand out in local search results and increase traffic to your business.